Season | Result | Host arena | Host city | Game MVP | Notes |
1978–1979 | Icelandic players 85, Foreign players 128 | Laugardalshöll | Reykjavík | | The Icelandic team was made up of players in the Icelandic national team.[2] |
1985–1986 | National Team 61, Press Select 71[3] | Laugardalshöll | Reykjavík | | The National Team was made up of players in the Icelandic national team.[4] |
1987–1988 | Landið 81, Suðurnes 79[1] | Hlíðarendi | Reykjavík | Pálmar Sigurðsson, Haukar | |
1988–1989 | Suðurnes 87, Landið 90 | Keflavík | Keflavík | Valur Ingimundarson, Tindastóll | The teams were selected by sports journalists.[5] |
1989–1990 | Suðurnes 132, Landið 129[6] | Keflavík | Keflavík | Teitur Örlygsson, Njarðvík | |
1990–1991 | Suðurnes 147, Landið 133 | Grindavík | Grindavík | Rondey Robinson Njarðvík | |
1991–1992 | Landið 151, Suðurnes 128 | Laugardalshöll | Reykjavík | Not selected | |
1992–1993 | A Group 128, B Group 157 | Hlíðarendi | Reykjavík | Not selected | The starting teams were selected by the readers of Morgunblaðið and Dagblaðið Vísir. The All-Star team coaches selected the remaining 7 players on each team.[7] |
1993–1994 | A Group 143, B Group 134 | Austurberg | Reykjavík | Frank Booker, Valur | Overtime |
1994–1995 | A Group 198, B Group 199[8] | Laugardalshöll | Reykjavík | John Rhodes, ÍR | Double overtime |
1995–1996 | Domestic 103, Foreign 116 | Smárinn | Kópavogur | Torrey John, Tindastóll | |
1996–1997 | Team Sprite 114, Team Esso 122[9] | Laugardalshöll | Reykjavík | Herman Myers, Grindavík | |
1997–1998 | Team Sprite 124, Team Esso 108 | Laugardalshöll | Reykjavík | Sherrick Simpson, Haukar | Teams selected by Benedikt Guðmundsson (Sprite) and Einar Einarsson (Esso) |
1998–1999 | Team Esso, Team Sprite | Hlíðarendi | Reykjavík | N/A | Game was first postponed due to bad weather and later canceled |
1999–2000 | Team Sprite 154, Team Esso 124 | Strandagata | Hafnarfjörður | Keith Veney, Njarðvík | |
2000–2001 | Team Doritos 131, Team Pepsi 136 | Ljónagryfjan | Njarðvík | Shawn Myers, Tindastóll | |
2001–2002 | Team Domestic 105, Team Foreign 113 | Ásvellir | Hafnarfjörður | Damon Johnson, Keflavík | |
2002–2003 | Team South 132, Team North 123 | Ásvellir | Hafnarfjörður | Stevie Johnson, Haukar | |
2003–2004 | Team South 136, Team North 133 | Seljaskóli | Reykjavík | Friðrik Erlendur Stefánsson, Njarðvík | |
2004–2005 | Team Domestic 113, Team Foreign 134 | Hlíðarendi | Reykjavík | Clifton Cook, Skallagrímur | |
2005–2006 | Team Domestic 109, Team Foreign 128 | DHL-Höllin | Reykjavík | A.J. Moye, Keflavík | |
2006–2007 | Team Domestic 120, Team Foreign 142[10] | DHL-Höllin | Reykjavík | Kevin Sowell, Þór Akureyri | |
2007–2008 | Team Domestic 137, Team Foreign 136[11] | Keflavík | Keflavík | A.J. Moye, Keflavík | |
2008–2009 | Team Úrvalsdeild 113, National Team Selection 111 | Ásvellir | Hafnarfjörður | Jason Dourisseau, KR | Held in December 2008. |
2009–2010 | Team Iceland Express 129, Team Shell 134 | Dalhús | Grafarvogur | Andre Dabney, Hamar | Held on 12 December 2009.[12] |
2010–2011 | Team Landsbyggðin 130, Team Capital Region 128 | Seljaskóli | Reykjavík | Lazar Trifunovic, Keflavík | Held on 11 December 2010. |
2011–2012 | Team Capital Region 142, Team Landsbyggðin 140 | Dalhús | Grafarvogur | Nathan Walkup, Fjölnir | |
2012–2013 | Team Icelandair 122, Team Domino's 148 | Ásgarður | Garðabær | Jay Threatt, Snæfell | Domestic players versus foreign players |
2013–2014 | Team Icelandair 140, Team Domino's 116 | Ásvellir | Hafnarfjörður | Junior Hairston, Stjarnan | |